Wallace Lake Supper Club: Your Destination for Classic Wisconsin Cuisine

We have been to Wallers on the Lake several times. We have never been disappointed. This evening was no exception. Started with drinks at the bar. Shelly our bartender was very friendly and attentive. We had a table of 4 for dinner. We all had something different. And we were very happy with our selections, for salads to sandwiches to entrees. In the warmer months they offer complementary boats rides (see included photo). Stunning sunset. We will certainly return. And highly recommend.

First time, came here for my Birthday dinner. The view of the lake is wonderful & you can sit outside. Waitress was outstanding and friendly. Wisconsin donuts, MUST TRY! Every thing was amazing. I would definitely come back if I was in the area & take the boat ride next time.

Beautiful restaurant on wallace lake. Outdoor seating. Supper club feel but they opened it up so it doesn't feel stuffy. The maple bourbon and blackberry bourbon drinks were good. Chopped salad came chopped up for you not over saused. Lightly grilled salmon for an additional twelve dollars, so deal for twenty eight. They could make a pink squirrel and also the raspberry cheesecake was very good. Split the pink sqirrel for us at no charge. Ribeye didn't disappoint either. Server, Briana, was very friendly and patient. Can't beat the ambiance at this updated supper club.

Everything about our dinner was perfect. We had best tasting Prime we've ever had & a blackened salmon bowl that was delicious. Then there are the desserts! Menu is varied and with many options. Beautiful view. We can't wait for our next visit!

We had a reservation and were seated quickly. The menu contained a variety of different and unique items. Each person in our party of five ordered a different meal and they were all delicious. Our server was efficient and friendly and didn’t try to hurry us along. The ambiance was warm and we weren’t overwhelmed by noise from other guests. This made for a memorable experience.

Fantastic experience! We arrived early enough, and they sat us right in front of the window— beautiful view. Very friendly staff. We ordered Cheese Curds, Shrimp Scampi & 4 cheese mac & cheese with chicken. The cheese curds were good, the scampi was great — I would suggest to tone down the lemon as it was very overpowering. I loved the grilled chicken ( I’ll order chicken from this place anytime) It was very flavorful & cooked perfectly. The mac & cheese, however, could use something to add flavor as it was very bland on it’s own. Loved the complimentary boat ride on the pontoon! I shared feedback of the mac & cheese with the gentlemen driving the pontoon boat and before we left, he gave us a certificate to return—which I did not expect, but appreciate! We will certainly do so to try more of their menu & more rides around the lake. This is a great place for cozy date nights with the significant other or gathering with friends.

Last nite, March 15, was our first time back since Wallace Lake Supper Club became Waller's on the Lake. Did not disappoint! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted warmly & shown to our reserved table promptly. Our server was friendly & attentive & well informed of the food/drink specials. Our party of six were celebrating a birthday. All of our food choices were delicious...the restaurant was VERY busy with many large groups but we never felt rushed. Highly recommend...we will be back very soon.

Wallers on the Lake is a fantastic spot with a great atmosphere! The prime rib was perfectly cooked, juicy, and full of flavor—definitely a standout. And the free boat rides add such a fun touch, giving the whole experience a unique and memorable twist. Friendly staff, great views, and delicious food make it easy to recommend! Perfect for a relaxed outing on the lake.